
ALTON – By Jayne and John Simmons. The authors are the owners of Alton Steel Inc., which has a contingent agreement to sell the former mill site to TerraWatt.
In the 1850s, St. Louis was the leading commercial hub of the American West. Its economy was fueled by the Mississippi, and its powerful river and ferry interests resisted railroad bridges that threatened their businesses. Chicago made the opposite bet, it embraced the expanding railroad network. By 1856, a railroad bridge crossed the Mississippi at Rock Island, connecting Chicago-oriented railroads to the West. St. Louis didn’t open its own railroad bridge until 1874, but by then much of the region’s trade had shifted north. The 1880 census showed Chicago had overtaken St. Louis in population; it became a lead Chicago would never surrender to St. Louis.
Alton has its own version of this history. The city was developed as a commercial rival to St. Louis, and for generations it prospered on glass, paper and steel. Over time, many of those industries cut back or left. Alton’s population, which exceeded 43,000 in 1960, has fallen to roughly 25,000, leaving fewer residents to support much of the infrastructure built for a larger city.
That history is relevant to the proposed moratorium on data centers, which was introduced at the Nov. 12 council meeting and now goes to the Committee of the Whole. Alton should scrutinize any major development, and residents are right to ask about environmental and economic effects. But a moratorium doesn’t answer those questions. The city is already weighing an independent review: a proposed agreement with Stantec Consulting to study the project’s plans, economic data and environmental impacts comes back before the Committee of the Whole on Dec. 7. That is how the questions get answered.
A moratorium could prevent the city from even accepting necessary applications to move this proposal through its established review process. The city should obtain the facts, establish clear standards, and then decide whether this project meets them. A blanket prohibition would eliminate opportunity for discourse.
The site itself makes the case for careful consideration. Cleaning up a property used for heavy industry for over a century will be expensive and complicated. Without a viable redevelopment plan, the property risks remaining a vacant industrial site for years, with little economic activity and no clear path toward productive reuse, while any cleanup would depend on a buyer.
Some have asked why we don’t simply clean up the site ourselves. It’s a fair question, and we take that responsibility seriously. We have already applied for demolition permits. Illinois environmental rules recognize that remediation requirements depend in part on a property’s intended future use. Without knowing whether the site will remain industrial or be converted to another use, it is difficult to establish the full scope and cost of redevelopment-related cleanup.
A closed mill earns nothing to pay for that work; redevelopment does. TerraWatt’s plan includes demolishing and remediating the site, so the cleanup would be done to the standard its new use requires and paid for by private investment, not by taxpayer funding.
The environmental comparison also matters, and it should be made honestly. A data center has real impacts that deserve review, especially its electricity demand. But it would not bring back the furnace emissions, slag and heavy truck traffic that came with more than a century of steelmaking on East Broadway.
Those impacts are also subject to oversight beyond City Hall. Any data center cannot simply demand electricity that the grid is unable to provide. Proposed power requirements must be evaluated through Ameren and applicable utility and regional transmission processes, with oversight under state and federal regulatory requirements. Those reviews are important safeguards, and Alton’s leaders should insist on understanding their findings before making a final decision.
For Alton to grow, it needs well-funded schools that give children a quality education and give families a reason to stay, infrastructure that keeps residents safe and attracts new ones, and the kind of readiness that draws businesses, including technology companies looking for a place to build. All of that requires a stronger tax base than the city has today. Redeveloping a large, underutilized industrial property is one of the most defining opportunities Alton has to strengthen its tax base to truly compete with other communities without consuming undeveloped land.
St. Louis spent more than a century living with the cost of underestimating the railroads. Alton can avoid that mistake. The council should drop the moratorium, require full information on power, water and site cleanup, hold the developer to clear commitments, and decide based on that evidence.
Alton has been left behind before. Let’s not choose it this time.
Opinions expressed in this section are solely those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of RiverBender.com or its affiliates. We provide a platform for community voices, but the responsibility for opinions rests with their authors.

